The additional return that investors require to deploy capital in higher-risk environments is the price of institutional weakness, paid by the populations that live in it.
What the Risk Premium Is
The risk premium is the additional return that investors require to compensate for the increased risk of investing in a specific environment relative to a lower-risk baseline. In the context of development finance, the risk premium required to attract private capital to low-income country investments reflects the specific institutional risks of those environments: the sovereign risk of policy reversal or expropriation, the regulatory risk of unpredictable rule changes, the currency risk of exchange rate volatility, and the counterparty risk of contracts that are difficult to enforce in domestic legal systems.
The geographic distribution of the risk premium is therefore the geographic distribution of institutional weakness: the highest risk premiums are required in the environments with the weakest institutions, which are also the environments where the development impact of investment would be highest. The risk premium creates a structural inversion: the capital is most expensive precisely where it would do the most good, and cheapest where development need is lowest.
The Cost Incidence
The cost of the risk premium is ultimately borne by the populations that live in the high-risk environment — through the higher cost of borrowed capital for governments and enterprises, the lower levels of investment that the high required returns exclude, and the terms of the investment that does occur, which must generate returns high enough to compensate investors for the institutional risks that the population lives with as a daily condition.
The risk premium is the price of institutional weakness, charged to the populations that are already paying all the other costs of living in a weakly governed environment. It is not a market failure — it is the market functioning correctly in an environment that institutional investment could make different.
Discussion