First Law: In the coordination economy, the actor who controls the coordination layer controls the value created in the production layer beneath it.
The First Structural Law
The first structural law of the coordination economy states that control of the coordination layer — the infrastructure through which buyers find sellers, through which producers reach consumers, through which workers connect to employers — confers leverage over the production layer that the coordination enables. This is not an axiom about markets in general; it is a specific observation about the structure of the modern economy in which the coordination layer and the production layer have separated in ways that make control of the former more valuable than control of the latter.
The empirical evidence for this law is abundant. The ride-sharing platform that coordinates between drivers and passengers captures more value per transaction than the driver who provides the transportation. The e-commerce marketplace that coordinates between sellers and buyers captures a significant share of the value created by the underlying commercial transactions. The app store that coordinates between software developers and device users captures a portion of the value generated by every application distributed through it. In each case, the coordination layer actor does not produce the primary service; it coordinates access to those who do, and captures value proportionate to its control over that coordination.
Implications of the First Law
The first law has direct implications for competitive strategy: the firm that competes only in the production layer in a market where a coordination layer has emerged is competing in the layer with lower returns. The worker whose labour is intermediated by a platform that controls the coordination layer occupies a structurally weaker position than the worker whose employer cannot access them except through that intermediation. The small business whose customer relationships are mediated by a platform that controls consumer discovery has ceded leverage over its own economics to the platform. The first law is not a prediction about what should happen — it is an observation about what does happen when coordination layers emerge and consolidate.
The first law of the coordination economy: control the layer where buyers find sellers and you control the economics of the transaction. Production is commoditised by the coordination layer above it. This is not a market failure — it is the market working as coordination economics predicts.
Discussion