Tenth Law: Coordination infrastructure that achieves systemic importance must be regulated as infrastructure — not as a competitive product market.
When Infrastructure Is Infrastructure
The tenth structural law of the coordination economy states that when coordination infrastructure achieves the level of scale and dependency that makes it systemic — when a significant portion of the economy depends on it for the coordination that economic activity requires — it must be governed as infrastructure rather than as a product in a competitive market. The historical precedent is clear: the telegraph, the telephone network, the railroad, and the financial payment system each achieved systemic importance at which point they were subject to the public interest regulation that infrastructure status requires — common carrier obligations, non-discrimination requirements, pricing oversight, and public service obligations that would not emerge from unregulated market competition.
The digital platforms that have achieved equivalent systemic importance in the coordination economy — the dominant search engine, the dominant social network, the dominant e-commerce marketplace, the dominant cloud infrastructure provider — have not yet been governed as infrastructure at equivalent scale, in part because the governance frameworks applicable to them were designed for a different era and in part because the political economy of platform regulation has favoured the incumbent positions of the platforms being regulated.
The Infrastructure Governance Toolkit
Governing coordination infrastructure as infrastructure requires a toolkit that goes beyond the competition law prohibitions and merger control that have been the primary tools of digital platform regulation to date. Common carrier obligations that require systemic coordination infrastructure to provide access on non-discriminatory terms. Interoperability mandates that prevent lock-in at scale. Data governance requirements that prevent the accumulation of data advantages that competition cannot address. And platform governance accountability requirements that bring the rule-making functions of systemic platforms within a framework of due process and appeal that their quasi-regulatory role requires.
The tenth law: systemic coordination infrastructure is public infrastructure in economic function regardless of its ownership structure. Governing it as a competitive market is governing it incorrectly — and the harms that result are the predictable consequence of the mismatch between governance framework and economic reality.
Discussion