American cities are the sites where the most complex governance challenges are most visible and where governance capacity is most unevenly distributed.
The Urban Governance Complexity
The governance of American cities involves a complexity that the formal governmental structure understates. The formal structure — the mayor, the city council, the city agencies — is the visible layer of urban governance. Beneath and alongside it are the special districts, the independent authorities, the school districts, the county governments, the state agencies with urban mandates, and the federal programmes with urban applications that together constitute the actual governance architecture of the American city. The coordination of these multiple governance actors around coherent urban policy objectives is the central institutional challenge of urban governance — and it is the challenge for which the formal governmental structure is least well-designed.
The urban governance failures that receive the most political attention — homelessness, public safety, transportation, housing affordability — are failures of coordination across this complex governance architecture as much as they are failures of individual policy or individual agency. The homelessness challenge requires the coordination of housing, mental health, substance use treatment, law enforcement, and social services — each governed by a different combination of city, county, state, and federal authority. The housing affordability challenge requires the coordination of zoning, infrastructure investment, finance regulation, and tenant protection — each governed by different actors with different constituencies and different legal authority. Addressing these challenges requires the governance coordination that the fragmented urban governance architecture makes structurally difficult.
Urban governance failures are governance architecture failures as much as they are policy failures. The city that cannot address its homelessness challenge often cannot do so not because the policy solutions are unknown but because the governance structure that would allow those solutions to be implemented coherently across the multiple agencies and levels of government involved does not exist. Building it is a governance reform challenge, not a policy challenge.
Discussion