The immigrant sees institutions that the native resident has stopped seeing. That visibility is an analytical advantage, and it is the contribution that the immigrant experience makes to the analysis of any institutional landscape.
The Visibility Advantage
The immigrant sees institutional features that the native resident has stopped seeing — not because the immigrant is more perceptive but because the immigrant lacks the normalisation that extended institutional familiarity produces. The American healthcare system's complexity, the American credit system's opacity, and the American immigration system's procedural arbitrariness are visible to the new immigrant in ways that they are not visible to the person who has been navigating these systems throughout their adult life and has normalised the features that the new arrival encounters as novel and often bewildering. The visibility that the new arrival has is the analytical raw material for the institutional analysis that the normalised resident cannot produce.
The immigrant's analytical advantage is not unlimited — it is specific to the institutional features that the unfamiliarity of the new context makes visible, and it declines over time as familiarity produces the normalisation that reduces visibility. The analytical window in which the new arrival sees the institutional landscape with fresh eyes is the window in which the comparative institutional analysis that is most revealing about the specific institutional choices embedded in the new country's institutional landscape can be produced. Capturing what is visible in that window — before normalisation obscures it — is the analytical discipline that the immigrant's specific institutional position enables.
The immigrant's analytical advantage is the visibility that unfamiliarity provides before normalisation reduces it. The analysis produced in that window — the observation of institutional features that the native resident has stopped seeing — is the specific contribution that the immigrant's experience makes to institutional analysis. This blog has tried to sustain that visibility past the point where it would normally fade, by maintaining the analytical distance that the institutional analysis framework requires.
Discussion