Five years of institutional analysis has produced a set of questions that are reliably productive when applied to any institutional problem. These are the questions worth keeping.
The Productive Questions
The questions that have proved most analytically productive across five years of institutional analysis are the questions that direct attention toward the mechanisms rather than the symptoms, the structural conditions rather than the specific events, and the governance choices rather than the natural order. They are: what is this institution actually optimising for? Who bears the cost when it fails? What would genuine improvement require? What is preventing the improvement that would be possible? Whose interests are served by the current failure? What would success look like and how would it be measured? And the meta-question that underlies all of them: is this a governance choice or a natural constraint, and if it is a governance choice, what would it take to make a different one?
These questions are productive because they are answerable — not with certainty, but with the specificity that the institutional record and the careful observation of institutional behaviour provide. They direct the analysis toward the specific institutional features that determine whether the institution is serving its purpose or something else, and toward the specific governance changes that would align institutional behaviour more closely with institutional purpose. The questions that ask only what happened, without asking why it happened and what governance choices produced the conditions that made it happen, are questions that produce narrative without analysis. The questions worth asking are the ones that produce the structural analysis that narrative alone cannot provide.
The questions worth keeping are the questions that move the analysis from what happened to why it happened, from the specific event to the structural conditions that produced it, and from the structural description to the governance choice that the structural description reveals. These questions are the analytical engine that drives institutional analysis from observation to understanding to the possibility of change.
Discussion